Peanut Butter and Company's line! It's more expensive than Jif, but when I went gluten and soy free, I couldn't have Nutella (I don't recall why, the last time we checked the ingredients, it's me-safe; it could have been the dairy free issue at the time, but whatever) and I was...cranky. Also, being forced to be dairy-free at the time and therefore even more cranky. The following made the year of dairy free and cranky far better:

http://ilovepeanutbutter.com/index.php/peanut-butter-1/darkchocolatedreams.html