Thanks for the insole advice. I've had a hard time finding insoles that fit (the edges of my wide feet overlap the edges of the insoles), or else putting an insole in a shoe makes the inside of the shoe too small for my foot. So those Drew shoes... gosh. Thank you!

And yeah, I need shoes I can wear to walk to the park, run around in, and also wear to an office.

I am very very leery of buying used shoes because even though a lot of used shoes were only worn literally a handful of times for me that is still sometimes enough to start wearing down the foot bed and cause me gait issues and pain. I have bought shoes in thrift stores, though, because I can try them on and walk around.